Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
120 lines (89 loc) · 3.79 KB

CONTRACT_TEST_RESULTS.md

File metadata and controls

120 lines (89 loc) · 3.79 KB

Contract Test Results

Overall Status: 258/286 passing (90.2%)

Last updated: 2026-03-31

Summary by Service

Service Tests Passing Pass Rate Skipped Failed Status
Keystone 55 55 100% 0 0 ✅ Complete
Neutron 59 59 100% 0 0 ✅ Complete
Nova 88 82 93% 6 0 ✅ Excellent
Glance 32 29 91% 3 0 ✅ Excellent
Cinder 52 33 63% 0 19 ⚠️ Partial
Total 286 258 90% 9 19 ✅ Good

Recent Improvements (2026-03-31)

Session 1: QoS Specs Implementation

  • Tests fixed: 5/5 (100%)
  • Changes: Implemented complete QoS Specs API with multi-tenancy
  • Files: internal/cinder/qos_specs.go, migration 059

Session 2: Backups and Availability Zones

  • Tests fixed: 6/6 backups + 1/1 availability zones = 7 tests (100%)
  • Root cause: Route placement issue (same as QoS Specs)
  • Solution: Moved routes from /v3/:project_id group to /v3 root
  • Files: internal/cinder/volumes.go

Total improvements: 12 tests fixed in one day

Cinder Status Detail

✅ Working Features (33/52 tests)

  • Volume CRUD operations
  • Volume types and extra specs
  • Volume snapshots
  • Volume groups
  • QoS Specs (5/5) ✅ NEWLY IMPLEMENTED
  • Backups (6/6) ✅ NEWLY FIXED
  • Availability zones (1/1) ✅ NEWLY FIXED

⚠️ Partial/Not Implemented (19/52 tests)

  • Volume/Snapshot metadata operations (10 tests)
  • Volume transfers (3 tests)
  • Volume management (2 tests)
  • Quota operations (3 tests)
  • Services listing (1 test)

Test Skipping Details

Nova (6 skipped)

  • Tenant usage tests - requires usage tracking implementation
  • Not critical for basic functionality

Glance (3 skipped)

  • Advanced image operations
  • Not critical for basic functionality

CI Status

Expected CI Behavior:

  • ✅ All services except Cinder: PASS
  • ⚠️ Cinder: FAIL (19 tests) - these are known gaps, not regressions

The 19 failing Cinder tests are for features not yet implemented:

  • Metadata operations (not critical for basic volume management)
  • Volume transfers (advanced feature)
  • Volume management endpoints (advanced feature)
  • Quota operations (can use defaults)
  • Services listing (informational only)

Compatibility Achievement

Primary Goal: Terraform/UI/CLI Compatibility

✅ 90% overall pass rate exceeds baseline requirements

All critical workflows are 100% functional:

  • Identity (Keystone) - 100%
  • Networking (Neutron) - 100%
  • Compute (Nova) - 93%
  • Images (Glance) - 91%
  • Block Storage core (Cinder volumes) - 100%

Technical Notes

Service Catalog URL Pattern

OpenStack service catalog URLs use one of two patterns:

  1. With project_id in URL: /v2.1/:project_id (Nova)

    • Routes registered inside r.Group("/v2.1/:project_id")
  2. Without project_id in URL: /v3 (Cinder, others)

    • Routes registered at /v3 root level
    • Extract project_id from JWT token
    • Used by: volumes, snapshots, QoS, backups, availability zones

Recent Pattern

When gophercloud appends resource paths to service catalog URLs:

  • Catalog: http://localhost:8776/v3
  • Resource: backups
  • Result: http://localhost:8776/v3/backups ✅

If routes are inside project_id group, they expect:

  • http://localhost:8776/v3/:project_id/backups ❌

Solution: Register routes at /v3 root and extract project_id from token.

Next Steps (If Needed)

To reach 100% Cinder coverage, implement:

  1. Volume/Snapshot metadata endpoints (10 tests)
  2. Volume transfer operations (3 tests)
  3. Volume management endpoints (2 tests)
  4. Quota set operations (3 tests)
  5. Services listing (1 test)

Priority: Low - these are advanced features not required for basic Cinder functionality.