Skip to content

docs: retain MR-15 unresolved evidence and resume maintenance - #68

Merged
deku2026 merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
plan/maintenance-mr15-observation
Oct 26, 2026
Merged

deku2026 merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
plan/maintenance-mr15-observation

Conversation

@deku2026

@deku2026 deku2026 commented Oct 26, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

MR-15 remains unresolved/deferred AR-22; no runtime repair or real-store pass is claimed. Historical #12 used real Windows Credential Manager when CrashConsistencyTests(420) found all 20 sampled values unavailable. Since 6978b0c, routine writer/reopen paths use private file-backed isolated keys, so current passing tests cannot validate the old path or establish its cause.

Read-only Windows audit: 1,940 retained logs, 11,920,238 bytes, 88 run directories/86 summaries (70 win,16 legacy without host;75 success,11 other), no read errors or size skips. Six explicit isolated case passes; no original diagnostic or alternate failure marker found within stated bounds. Retain scripts/manifests/hashes, limits and nonrecurrence boundary. No new crash/stress batch, real-store or credential-file operation, assertion/retry change, or source/Design patch. MR-16 recovery proposal/block remains.

Add AR-22 procedure and AF-NODE-02 acceptance link/notes, task state unchanged; append one note through Plan CLI. Update MR-15 and both handoffs for the owner's resumed continuous execution/per-item counts. Totals:35 disposed,66 open,3 deferred,1 blocked of105;70 still unresolved. MR-17 next, skip blocked MR-16. No later-feature activation.

Reviewed head130c44d98cdc3b28ed133087b56db2dd9475f196, treeef959994e60ba129c8aa1099deafc26ae70f02c7, base65e26947f283e6307cff4acafc8486ff0b05737d. Author Plan/Design zero errors, protoc25/both schemas,48 tool tests with20 Windows skips, diff clean. Merged as 09d56794db7fd00461912dcf1c2645c8819619f9 after full native Windows4 steps/3 s and Linux4 steps/26 s passed. Every result, both wrapper exits0 and required exact-head success statuses read. Both contexts Design2d9995e78c4aa0f6327371ab0b5639857718da5c remained unchanged on fresh fetches from both hosts immediately before merge. Direct review, final gate.

A transient Windows MCP read error recovered; commit/push was checked through GitHub and native exit0 without relaunch. Observation, current handoff.

OpenAI Codex direct work/review alone under explicit no-other-model/agent instruction.

Generated by OpenAI Codex.

Co-Authored-By: OpenAI Codex <noreply@openai.com>

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Direct review at exact head130c44d98cdc3b28ed133087b56db2dd9475f196, treeef959994e60ba129c8aa1099deafc26ae70f02c7, base65e26947f283e6307cff4acafc8486ff0b05737d. Seven-file diff read against PR12 historical note, f5c622d TestSecretStores selection, 6978b0c backend change, current CrashConsistencyTests/TaskSecrets/NodeDataKeyRing, and retained audit manifests. No unresolved findings. The record distinguishes missing cause from nonrecurrence and present isolated-key evidence; MR-15 stays unresolved/deferred AR-22, not fixed. 1940 files/11920238bytes/88 directories/86 summaries are audit scope, not fresh runs; 16 legacy host-unspecified and11 non-success summaries are not passes. Only six explicit current-format case mentions, with alternate-marker/context check; original raw capture not found only within stated bounds. AR-22 stays open, grants no OS-store/credential-file operation or stress, preserves MR-16 block, changes no task state. AF-NODE-02 adds only AR-22 link/notes; exactly one CLI ledger note at2026-10-26T02:27:22Z. Handoffs truthfully record the owner's resumed continuous execution and per-item counts. 35 disposed+66open+3deferred+1blocked=105; total unresolved70. Author validation/traceability zero errors,48 tests with20 Windows skips, diff clean. Native full final-head Plan statuses and fresh unchanged Design context on both hosts still gate merge. OpenAI Codex alone under explicit no-agent instruction; no independent reviewer claimed.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Final merge gate: exact head130c44d98cdc3b28ed133087b56db2dd9475f196/treeef959994e60ba129c8aa1099deafc26ae70f02c7, fresh main/base65e26947f283e6307cff4acafc8486ff0b05737d. Complete native Windows full4/3 s (20261026-023048-130c44d98cdc-win) and Linux full4/26 s (20261026-103042-130c44d98cdc-linux) passed. All eight results and both wrapper exits0 read; both required exact-head engine statuses success, owner-hosted check skipped. Each summary records Design main2d9995e78c4aa0f6327371ab0b5639857718da5c; fetched Design separately on both native hosts immediately before merge and it remains unchanged. Fresh Plan refs/head/tree unchanged. Direct review6406909824 has no unresolved findings. No competing formal build/test, no old-head/context status reuse. MR-15 remains unresolved/deferred AR-22, not a repair/pass; current backend evidence does not substitute for the historical real-store cause. Merge this record, report70 still unresolved (66open,3deferred,1blocked), then continue MR-17 while preserving MR-16 block.

@deku2026
deku2026 merged commit 09d5679 into main Oct 26, 2026
3 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant