Repository navigation
docs: retain MR-15 unresolved evidence and resume maintenance - #68
Conversation
Co-Authored-By: OpenAI Codex <noreply@openai.com>
|
Direct review at exact head130c44d98cdc3b28ed133087b56db2dd9475f196, treeef959994e60ba129c8aa1099deafc26ae70f02c7, base65e26947f283e6307cff4acafc8486ff0b05737d. Seven-file diff read against PR12 historical note, f5c622d TestSecretStores selection, 6978b0c backend change, current CrashConsistencyTests/TaskSecrets/NodeDataKeyRing, and retained audit manifests. No unresolved findings. The record distinguishes missing cause from nonrecurrence and present isolated-key evidence; MR-15 stays unresolved/deferred AR-22, not fixed. 1940 files/11920238bytes/88 directories/86 summaries are audit scope, not fresh runs; 16 legacy host-unspecified and11 non-success summaries are not passes. Only six explicit current-format case mentions, with alternate-marker/context check; original raw capture not found only within stated bounds. AR-22 stays open, grants no OS-store/credential-file operation or stress, preserves MR-16 block, changes no task state. AF-NODE-02 adds only AR-22 link/notes; exactly one CLI ledger note at2026-10-26T02:27:22Z. Handoffs truthfully record the owner's resumed continuous execution and per-item counts. 35 disposed+66open+3deferred+1blocked=105; total unresolved70. Author validation/traceability zero errors,48 tests with20 Windows skips, diff clean. Native full final-head Plan statuses and fresh unchanged Design context on both hosts still gate merge. OpenAI Codex alone under explicit no-agent instruction; no independent reviewer claimed. |
|
Final merge gate: exact head130c44d98cdc3b28ed133087b56db2dd9475f196/treeef959994e60ba129c8aa1099deafc26ae70f02c7, fresh main/base65e26947f283e6307cff4acafc8486ff0b05737d. Complete native Windows full4/3 s (20261026-023048-130c44d98cdc-win) and Linux full4/26 s (20261026-103042-130c44d98cdc-linux) passed. All eight results and both wrapper exits0 read; both required exact-head engine statuses success, owner-hosted check skipped. Each summary records Design main2d9995e78c4aa0f6327371ab0b5639857718da5c; fetched Design separately on both native hosts immediately before merge and it remains unchanged. Fresh Plan refs/head/tree unchanged. Direct review6406909824 has no unresolved findings. No competing formal build/test, no old-head/context status reuse. MR-15 remains unresolved/deferred AR-22, not a repair/pass; current backend evidence does not substitute for the historical real-store cause. Merge this record, report70 still unresolved (66open,3deferred,1blocked), then continue MR-17 while preserving MR-16 block. |
MR-15 remains unresolved/deferred AR-22; no runtime repair or real-store pass is claimed. Historical #12 used real Windows Credential Manager when CrashConsistencyTests(420) found all 20 sampled values unavailable. Since 6978b0c, routine writer/reopen paths use private file-backed isolated keys, so current passing tests cannot validate the old path or establish its cause.
Read-only Windows audit: 1,940 retained logs, 11,920,238 bytes, 88 run directories/86 summaries (70 win,16 legacy without host;75 success,11 other), no read errors or size skips. Six explicit isolated case passes; no original diagnostic or alternate failure marker found within stated bounds. Retain scripts/manifests/hashes, limits and nonrecurrence boundary. No new crash/stress batch, real-store or credential-file operation, assertion/retry change, or source/Design patch. MR-16 recovery proposal/block remains.
Add AR-22 procedure and AF-NODE-02 acceptance link/notes, task state unchanged; append one note through Plan CLI. Update MR-15 and both handoffs for the owner's resumed continuous execution/per-item counts. Totals:35 disposed,66 open,3 deferred,1 blocked of105;70 still unresolved. MR-17 next, skip blocked MR-16. No later-feature activation.
Reviewed head130c44d98cdc3b28ed133087b56db2dd9475f196, treeef959994e60ba129c8aa1099deafc26ae70f02c7, base65e26947f283e6307cff4acafc8486ff0b05737d. Author Plan/Design zero errors, protoc25/both schemas,48 tool tests with20 Windows skips, diff clean. Merged as
09d56794db7fd00461912dcf1c2645c8819619f9after full native Windows4 steps/3 s and Linux4 steps/26 s passed. Every result, both wrapper exits0 and required exact-head success statuses read. Both contexts Design2d9995e78c4aa0f6327371ab0b5639857718da5c remained unchanged on fresh fetches from both hosts immediately before merge. Direct review, final gate.A transient Windows MCP read error recovered; commit/push was checked through GitHub and native exit0 without relaunch. Observation, current handoff.
OpenAI Codex direct work/review alone under explicit no-other-model/agent instruction.
Generated by OpenAI Codex.