This repository holds code, data, and other files related to the third data chapter of Courtney Stuart’s PhD research at the University of Oxford Seascape Ecology Lab (P.I. Dr Lisa Wedding). This study was made possible by two decades of ecological monitoring across the coral reefs of Moorea, French Polynesia, conducted by the Moorea Coral Reef Long Term Ecological Research Site (MCR LTER). Funded by the U.S. National Science Foundation, the MCR LTER maintains an extensive, long-term ecological database.
Stuart, C. E., Young, M. A., Davis, A. C. D., Green, S. J., Pittman, S. J., Brooks, A. J., Krumbholz, H., and Wedding, L. M. (In Review). Reef geomorphology shapes fish communities more strongly than benthic conditions and disturbance in Moorea, French Polynesia. Ecography.
Resolving how environmental conditions, phylogeny, traits, and random spatio-temporal effects influence coral reef fish assemblage structure is important for predicting and managing reef resilience in a changing ocean. We quantified their relative contributions to occurrence patterns for 149 species using 19 years of data from Moorea, French Polynesia. Applying a multivariate hierarchical joint species distribution model, we partitioned community-level variation in occurrence and identified residual species associations. On average, environmental covariates accounted for 88% of the explained variation in species’ occurrence, while random spatio-temporal effects accounted for the remaining 12%. Reef geomorphic zone (39%) and depth (17%) contributed most strongly, followed by distance to land (14%) and seafloor curvature (12%). Conversely, pulse disturbances, including a tropical cyclone, marine heatwaves, and corallivorous starfish outbreaks, each explained <5% of variation at the community level, although responses were detected for a subset of species. Species’ responses to environmental covariates exhibited an intermediate phylogenetic signal, indicating partial niche conservatism among closely related taxa. Traits associated with foraging, locomotion, habitat use, and reproductive behaviour explained only 1% of variation in occurrence and 7% of variation in environmental responses, suggesting generally weak trait-based structuring at the community level. Nevertheless, several trait-environment interactions were supported with ≥95% posterior probability, particularly for responses to pulse disturbances and benthic substratum composition. Positive and negative residual co-occurrence was detected among 963 and 365 species pairs, respectively, suggesting potential interspecific interactions such as cooperative foraging and competition. Together, these results indicate that Moorea’s reef fish community is structured primarily by persistent geomorphological conditions and phylogenetically conserved niche relationships, while traits and pulse disturbances play more limited roles. These findings have direct implications for conservation and restoration initiatives seeking to strengthen the long-term resilience of Moorea’s coral reefs.
Coral reefs, ecological niches, French Polynesia, joint species distribution model, reef fish, reef resilience
You are welcome to use and borrow from this repository according to the license below. However, access to the raw datasets must first be approved by the original data collectors. Please email your inquiries to Courtney Stuart (@courtney.seascape@gmail.com or @courtney.stuart@mansfield.ox.ac.uk) so that your requests can be forwarded to the appropriate contacts.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
