Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
# Decisions

## D-001

- Question: Create a GitHub issue for this fix (draft - Title - "Fix CI failure on setup-php 2.40.0 bump (PR #8)"; Problem - Dependabot PR #8 fails the P8.5 / L13.* / prefer-stable / ubuntu-latest job; Outcome - PR #8 checks go green, not merged; Out of scope - merging), or skip the ticket and fix the PR branch directly?
- Choice: Create the issue
- Rationale: none given (answered in RingMaster)
- Date: 2026-10-27
- Raised by: ticket

## D-002

- Question: Failing job is a PHPStan bootstrap error (missing Testbench bootstrap/cache/packages.php in a parallel worker), and PR #8's run is from 2026-10-15 while main has been green since. How should the job be fixed?
- Choice: Rebase PR #8 and re-run first, change only the workflow if it still fails
- Rationale: A campaign is also dropping Cortex's paratest conflict; if the rebased run fails on composer resolving paratest, wait for that PR rather than fixing it here. (answered in RingMaster)
- Date: 2026-10-28
- Raised by: shape

## D-003

- Question: If the rebased run still fails on the PHPStan bootstrap race, where should the workflow fix land?
- Choice: Open a separate PR against main with the fix, then rebase PR #8 onto it
- Rationale: none given (answered in RingMaster)
- Date: 2026-10-28
- Raised by: spec-review

## D-004

- Question: How many consecutive green runs of the previously failing P8.5 / L13.* / prefer-stable / ubuntu-latest job count as proof before the job reports 'no change needed'?
- Choice: Two consecutive green runs on the same head (re-run once)
- Rationale: none given (answered in RingMaster)
- Date: 2026-10-28
- Raised by: spec-review

## D-005

- Question: If Dependabot does not rebase PR #8 (comment ignored, PR closed or superseded), how should criterion 1 be satisfied?
- Choice: Rebase manually and push to the PR branch
- Rationale: none given (answered in RingMaster)
- Date: 2026-10-28
- Raised by: spec-review

## D-006

- Question: Approve the spec for Fix CI failure on Dependabot setup-php 2.40.0 bump as written (acceptance criteria 1-6 after the D-003..D-005 recheck)?
- Choice: Approve
- Rationale: none given (answered in RingMaster)
- Date: 2026-10-28
- Raised by: approval

## D-007

- Question: PR #8 is green on two consecutive CI runs with no repo file changes, but the local gate fails on main: KeenInCiTest reads a stale gitignored composer.lock, and ringside check reports stale generated files. Mark this job done, or hold it?
- Choice: Mark done and propose a follow-up task to fix the local gate drift
- Rationale: none given (answered in RingMaster)
- Date: 2026-10-28
- Raised by: build
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
id: 2026-10-27-1055-fix-setup-php-2-40-0-bump
title: Fix CI failure on Dependabot setup-php 2.40.0 bump
status: done
review_passes: 2
created: 2026-10-27
ticket: { provider: github, key: "#13", url: "https://github.com/Refactor-Circus/Cortex/issues/13" }
standards: {}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
[]
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
# References

- `.github/workflows/tests.yml`: the only file PR #8 changes; the matrix is `P{php} / L{laravel} / {stability} / {os}`.
- Failed run: https://github.com/Refactor-Circus/Cortex/actions/runs/38800233800/job/116647049225 — PHPStan bootstrap fails on a missing Testbench `bootstrap/cache/packages.php`.
- Passing runs on main (for example 40451198391) show the same workflow green without the bump.
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
# Fix CI failure on setup-php 2.40.0 bump — Shaping Notes

Ticket: https://github.com/Refactor-Circus/Cortex/issues/13

## Scope

Dependabot PR #8 (`shivammathur/setup-php` 2.37.2 → 2.40.0, one line in `.github/workflows/tests.yml`) has one red job: `P8.5 / L13.* / prefer-stable / ubuntu-latest`. Outcome: PR #8's checks go green. Out of scope: merging PR #8.

## Decisions

- D-001: GitHub issue created (answered in RingMaster).
- D-002: Rebase PR #8 and re-run first; change only the workflow if it still fails. If the rebased run fails on composer resolving paratest, wait for the campaign PR that drops Cortex's paratest conflict instead of fixing it here.

## Context

- The failing step is PHPStan, not setup-php: "Laravel framework bootstrap failed ... require(vendor/orchestra/testbench-core/laravel/bootstrap/cache/packages.php): Failed to open stream" in a parallel worker (run 38800233800, 2026-10-15).
- The other three jobs of that run (prefer-lowest on ubuntu and windows, prefer-stable on windows) passed.
- The PR run predates 2026-10-27; every `tests.yml` run on main and on the later branches since passed (latest on main 2026-10-27). PR #8 has not been re-run on current main.
- Leading hypothesis: a race creating Testbench's `bootstrap/cache/packages.php` across PHPStan parallel workers, not a setup-php regression. To confirm: rebase PR #8 (`@dependabot rebase`) and re-run; if it stays red, reproduce locally with `composer analyse`.
- The fix is a change to the PR branch or a workflow/PHPStan config tweak (for example, warm the Testbench package cache before PHPStan), not a Cortex source change.

## Standards

None of the local standards govern CI workflow files. The compat skill (`package-compatibility`) applies for the matrix.
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
# Spec review

## Round 1

Changes to spec.md, and why:

- Acceptance criteria extended to six. Criterion 1 now lists the evidence of the rebase (head SHA change, merge-base with main, run id) and notes Dependabot's reduced token; an unresponsive or closed PR is recorded and handled per the open question.
- Criterion 2 now requires the run URL, per-job results, an unconfirmed-race statement, and an unchanged one-line PR diff.
- Criterion 3 now requires reproducing or explaining the cause first, names the allowed files, defines the pass condition (all matrix jobs green, no "Failed to open stream ... packages.php" in the PHPStan log), and says what to do when a push is refused. Run counts and fix location are left to the open questions.
- Criterion 4 now names the paratest failure signature and ends with a blocked release and a resume note naming the campaign PR.
- New criterion 5 defines the end state for any other failure: no change, record on #13, release as failed.
- Criterion 6 (was 5) states the file boundary, checkable with `git diff --name-only`.
- Out of scope now excludes composer.json, other workflows, matrix changes and other Dependabot PRs.
- Risks now cover Dependabot ceasing to manage the branch after a human push, the `workflow` token scope, and a closed or superseded PR.
- Left unchanged on purpose: the four open questions (fix location, green run count for the P8.5 job, rebase fallback, full-matrix run count).

## Pass 2: recheck of D-003, D-004, D-005

All three decisions had landed in the Addendum. The body still contradicted them, so spec.md was changed:

- Criterion 1: manual rebase when Dependabot ignores the comment (D-005); for a manual rebase, the merge-base evidence is checked against the `main` tip at push time; a closed or superseded PR is recorded on #13 with no other change.
- Criterion 2: two consecutive green runs on the same head (D-004), with both run URLs on #13; a failed re-run is handled by criterion 3, 4 or 5.
- Criterion 3: the fix goes in a separate PR against `main` (D-003); the job is released as blocked with a resume note naming that PR, since merging it is the user's call; on resume, PR #8 is rebased and must pass twice.
- Criterion 6: checked per PR (PR #8 = one-line bump; fix PR = `tests.yml` and/or the PHPStan config).
- Risks: updated for two green runs, the stale branch after a manual rebase, and the `workflow` token scope on both pushes.
- Open questions: none.
42 changes: 42 additions & 0 deletions docs/agent/specs/2026-10-27-1055-fix-setup-php-2-40-0-bump/spec.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
# Fix CI failure on setup-php 2.40.0 bump

Ticket: https://github.com/Refactor-Circus/Cortex/issues/13

## Goal

Dependabot PR #8 (`shivammathur/setup-php` 2.37.2 → 2.40.0) goes green, so a maintainer can merge it. Merging is not part of this job.

## Acceptance criteria

1. PR #8's branch is rebased onto current `main` (`@dependabot rebase`), and `tests.yml` runs on the rebased head. Evidence, recorded on issue #13: the PR head SHA changed, its merge-base equals the `main` tip when the comment was posted, and the run id of the `tests.yml` run on that head. The run executes under Dependabot's reduced token and secrets. If Dependabot ignores the comment, record that on #13 and rebase PR #8's branch manually onto `main` and push it (D-005); if it is closed or superseded, record that on #13 and make no other change. When the rebase is manual there is no comment, so the merge-base evidence is measured against the `main` tip at push time.
2. If every job of the run passes, including `P8.5 / L13.* / prefer-stable / ubuntu-latest`, and a single re-run of the workflow on the same head also passes every job (two consecutive green runs, D-004), no file changes: the PR diff is still the one-line setup-php bump, and the result is noted on issue #13 (D-002). The note includes both run URLs, the per-job results, and a statement that the race hypothesis is unconfirmed. If the re-run fails, treat it as the error that run shows (criterion 3, 4 or 5).
3. If the PHPStan bootstrap error ("Failed to open stream ... bootstrap/cache/packages.php") still occurs, first reproduce it locally (`composer analyse`) or explain the cause from the log, and record the cause on #13. Only then is a change made, and only to `.github/workflows/tests.yml` or the repo's PHPStan config file. The change goes in a separate PR against `main`, never onto Dependabot's branch (D-003). Merging that PR is the user's call: release this job as blocked with a resume note naming the fix PR, and on resume rebase PR #8 onto the merged `main`. Pass condition: the `tests.yml` run on PR #8's rebased head has every matrix job green, including `P8.5 / L13.* / prefer-stable / ubuntu-latest`, the PHPStan step log has no "Failed to open stream ... packages.php" line, and a single re-run on the same head is also fully green (D-004). If a push is refused (for example a token without the `workflow` scope, or a protected branch), release the job with that reason and do not retry blindly.
4. If the rebased run fails because composer cannot resolve paratest (identified by a composer "Your requirements could not be resolved" error naming paratest in the install step, as opposed to a prefer-lowest/prefer-stable difference), no fix is made here. Record it on #13, link the blocking campaign PR, and release the job as blocked (not done) with a resume note naming that PR (D-002).
5. If the rebased run fails for any other cause (a real setup-php 2.40.0 regression, or a different job failing), make no change: record the failing step and log excerpt on #13 and release the job as failed.
6. Checked per PR with `git diff --name-only` against `main`: PR #8 touches only `.github/workflows/tests.yml` (the setup-php bump). If criterion 3 applies, the separate fix PR touches only `.github/workflows/tests.yml` and/or the PHPStan config file. No file under `src/` changes in either.

## Design

No code design. The work is a rebase and a CI re-run; a workflow tweak (for example, warming the Testbench package cache before PHPStan) is a fallback only, per D-002. Order of fallbacks: rebase and re-run, then workflow/PHPStan config; paratest failures are out of this job.

## Out of scope

- Merging PR #8.
- Dropping Cortex's paratest conflict (separate campaign PR).
- Changes to Cortex source.
- `composer.json`, other workflows, matrix changes, and other Dependabot PRs.

## Risks and open questions

- The failure may be a flaky race, so green runs do not prove the cause; acceptance requires two consecutive green runs on the same head (D-004).
- A paratest resolution failure blocks this job until the campaign PR lands.
- A manual rebase pushed to PR #8's branch (D-005) stops Dependabot from rebasing or updating it, so the PR can go stale again. Pushing to `.github/workflows/*` also needs a token with the `workflow` scope, for the manual rebase and for the fix PR.
- If PR #8 is closed or superseded, note it on #13 and do no new work.

## Addendum 2026-10-28 (D-003, D-004, D-005)

These answers close the open questions above and override the criteria where they differ.

- Green proof (D-004): criteria 2 and 3 pass only with two consecutive green `tests.yml` runs on the same head (re-run once after the first green run); both run URLs go on #13.
- Fix location (D-003): if the PHPStan bootstrap error still occurs, the workflow/PHPStan config fix goes in a separate PR against `main`, not onto Dependabot's branch. Once it is merged, PR #8 is rebased onto it and criterion 3's pass condition is checked on that head. Criterion 6 then applies to each PR separately: PR #8 stays the one-line setup-php bump, the fix PR touches only `.github/workflows/tests.yml` and/or the PHPStan config file. Merging the fix PR is the user's call.
- No Dependabot rebase (D-005): if `@dependabot rebase` is ignored, rebase PR #8's branch manually onto `main` and push to the PR branch, then continue with criterion 1's evidence. If the PR is closed or superseded, the Risks note above still applies.
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
# Standards for Fix CI failure on setup-php 2.40.0 bump

No standard from `docs/agent/standards.index.yml` governs CI workflow files, and no Cortex source changes. The `package-compatibility` skill applies if the workflow matrix is touched.

| Standard | File | Source | Why it applies |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| none | - | - | CI-only change |
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
# Tasks: Fix CI failure on setup-php 2.40.0 bump

## Group 1: Rebase PR #8 and prove CI green
depends on: none
files: .github/workflows/tests.yml (only if criterion 3 applies, in a separate PR against main; never on PR #8's branch)
criteria: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6

- [x] 1.1 Write the checks first: record the `main` tip SHA, PR #8's current head SHA, and the failing job's log (`gh run view <run> --log-failed`) on issue #13 as the baseline; define the pass check as `gh pr view 8 --json statusCheckRollup` showing every matrix job green and `git diff --name-only main...<PR #8 head>` listing only `.github/workflows/tests.yml`
- [x] 1.2 Check PR #8 is still open; if closed or superseded, note it on #13 and stop with no other change
- [x] 1.3 Comment `@dependabot rebase` on PR #8; if Dependabot ignores it, rebase the branch manually onto `main` and push it (D-005); a refused push releases the job with that reason
- [x] 1.4 Record on #13: new head SHA, merge-base equal to the `main` tip, and the run id of the `tests.yml` run on that head
- [x] 1.5 If every job is green, re-run the workflow once on the same head; if both runs are green, note both run URLs, per-job results and "race hypothesis unconfirmed" on #13, with no file changes (D-002, D-004)
- [x] 1.6 If the PHPStan "Failed to open stream ... packages.php" error recurs, reproduce with `composer analyse` or explain it from the log, record the cause on #13, open a separate fix PR against `main` touching only `.github/workflows/tests.yml` and/or the PHPStan config, then `release-task` as blocked with a resume note naming the fix PR (D-003); on resume, rebase PR #8 onto the merged `main` and repeat 1.4 and 1.5 (not needed: the error did not recur)
- [x] 1.7 If composer fails resolving paratest, record it on #13 with the blocking campaign PR link and `release-task` as blocked; for any other failure, record the failing step and log excerpt on #13 and `release-task` with `failed: true` (no change made) (not needed: both runs green)
- [x] 1.8 Verify criterion 6: `git diff --name-only main` per PR touches only the allowed files and nothing under `src/`; run `composer test` if any file changed (only `.github/workflows/tests.yml` on PR #8; no file changed, so no `composer test`)
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
# Verification: Fix CI failure on setup-php 2.40.0 bump

Date: 2026-10-28 · Result: FAIL (local gate only; every acceptance criterion passes, and the job changed no repo file)

| Check | Result | Detail |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Criterion 1: PR #8 rebased onto `main`, `tests.yml` ran on the new head | pass | `@dependabot rebase` ignored; manual rebase per D-005. Head `2567b56` → `8a2bde7`, merge-base `c914866` (the `main` tip at push time), run 40637729378. Recorded on #13 (comment 6461508557) |
| Criterion 2: two consecutive green runs, no file changes, note on #13 | pass | Run 40637729378 attempts 1 and 2: all 4 jobs success, including `P8.5 - L13.* - prefer-stable - ubuntu-latest`; both URLs, per-job table and "race hypothesis unconfirmed" on #13 |
| Criterion 3: PHPStan bootstrap error handling | pass (not triggered) | No "Failed to open stream ... packages.php" line in attempt 1's log; no fix PR needed |
| Criterion 4: paratest resolution failure | pass (not triggered) | Original failure was the paratest conflict, fixed on `main` by #14; the rebased runs resolve |
| Criterion 5: other failure | pass (not triggered) | Both runs green |
| Criterion 6: PR #8 touches only `.github/workflows/tests.yml`, nothing under `src/` | pass | `git diff --name-only main...8a2bde7` → `.github/workflows/tests.yml` |
| Tasks | pass | Every box in `tasks.md` ticked |
| Full gate (`composer test`) | fail | 655/656 pass; 1 failure in `tests/Feature/Compat/KeenInCiTest.php`. Pre-existing: the working tree is `main` with no tracked changes. PHPStan and Pint pass |
| Standards drift (`vendor/bin/ringside check`) | fail | "Generated files are stale or missing. Run: vendor/bin/ringside sync". Pre-existing, unrelated to this job |

## Failures

`composer test`:

```
{"tool":"pest","result":"failed","tests":656,"passed":655,"failed":1,
"failures":[{"test":"...KeenInCiTest::it keeps refactor-circus/keen in require-dev with a lock entry",
"file":"tests/Feature/Compat/KeenInCiTest.php","line":93,
"message":"Failed asserting that an array contains 'refactor-circus/keen'."}]}
```

Cause: the test reads the root `composer.lock`, which is gitignored (`.gitignore:6`) and stale in this checkout. It has no `refactor-circus/keen` entry, although `vendor/refactor-circus/keen` is installed as a symlink by the local (`composer.local.json`) install. CI makes a fresh lock and passes this test on both runs.

`vendor/bin/ringside check`:

```
ringside: 1 problem(s)
Generated files are stale or missing. Run: vendor/bin/ringside sync
```

## Tasks to reopen

None. Neither failure comes from this job's work, which changed no repo file. They are local-environment problems on `main`. Whether that blocks `done` is questions.yml Q-001.
Loading
Loading