Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
2 changes: 1 addition & 1 deletion README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ As a proof of concept, the jurisdictional-direct leg covers eleven crops grown i

![Forest cleared for cropland in a few concentrated blocks of Matopiba, Brazil, when it happened, and the emissions it released beneath today's soybean](docs/figures/soy-brazil-matopiba-methodology.png)

*Matopiba, Brazil. **Top left:** the five-year span each converted pixel was charged to, darkest most recent — clearance falls in a few blocks rather than advancing as a front, and most of it between 2006 and 2015. **Top right:** which of the five conversions fired — forest → cropland in those blocks, rangeland → cropland as the thin scatter across the western half, and a band of pasture → cropland down the southern frontier where soybean is now densest. **Bottom:** MapSPAM soybean area in 2000 and 2020, settling on the same blocks the top row shows converting. **Right:** the 20-year linearly-discounted per-hectare emissions those conversions released, before any crop is named — bright on the forest blocks and not on the rangeland scatter, because forest carries far more carbon per hectare. The statistical leg then divides these emissions among the crops and pastureland that expanded locally, in proportion to each one's share of that expansion.*
*Matopiba, Brazil. **Top left:** the year each converted pixel's source class ended, 2001 to 2020, darker more recent — clearance falls in a few blocks rather than advancing as a front. **Top right:** which of the five conversions fired — forest → cropland in those blocks, a band of pasture → cropland down the southern frontier where soybean is now densest, and forest → pasture and rangeland conversions scattered across the rest. **Bottom:** MapSPAM soybean area in 2000 and 2020, settling on the same blocks the top row shows converting. **Right:** the per-hectare emissions those conversions released, vegetation plus soil, before they are discounted by conversion year and before any crop is named — bright on the forest blocks and dim on the scatter, because forest carries far more carbon per hectare. The statistical leg then divides the emissions on land that became cropland among the crops that expanded locally, in proportion to each one's share of that expansion, and the emissions on land that became pasture among the herds grazing it.*

## Why are we publishing this?

Expand Down
Binary file modified docs/figures/soy-brazil-matopiba-methodology.png
Loading
Sorry, something went wrong. Reload?
Sorry, we cannot display this file.
Sorry, this file is invalid so it cannot be displayed.
4 changes: 2 additions & 2 deletions docs/further_research.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -162,7 +162,7 @@ The consequence is that the nine 2005 crops read as expansion from zero across t

## Emissions attributed to no crop are reported rather than spread over the modeled crops

**Issue**: Shares add up to at most one, and whatever they leave over goes to no commodity. It is published for each jurisdiction as the `UNATTRIBUTED` row, so the commodity rows plus that row add up to the emissions total, but no emissions factor includes it. The row is an allocation remainder, so its amount does not by itself identify the crop responsible. It holds the part of each cell taken by the fourteen MapSPAM crops this leg does not model, and also conversion in cells without positive measured expansion: where neither cropland nor pasture grew, every share is zero and the whole forest, grassland and cropland peat conversion charge lands in this row. That conversion may be gross change hidden by net area change, or disagreement between the input maps. Both kinds of share leave something over, and the peatland-occupation shares leave more. The figures below predate the GACED30 and Global Pasture Watch destinations and need a re-measure on the current pipeline:
**Issue**: Shares add up to at most one, and whatever they leave over goes to no commodity. It is published for each jurisdiction as the `UNATTRIBUTED` row, so the commodity rows plus that row add up to the emissions total, but no emissions factor includes it. The row is an allocation remainder, so its amount does not by itself identify the crop responsible. It holds the part of each cell taken by the fourteen MapSPAM crops this leg does not model, and also conversion to cropland in cells without positive measured crop expansion: where no crop grew, every crop's share is zero and everything converted to cropland lands in this row. That conversion may be gross change hidden by net area change, or disagreement between the input maps. Both kinds of share leave something over, and the peatland-occupation shares leave more. The figures below predate the GACED30 and Global Pasture Watch destinations and need a re-measure on the current pipeline:

| window | conversion shares | peatland-occupation shares |
| --------- | ----------------: | -------------------------: |
Expand All @@ -185,7 +185,7 @@ WRI reaches the same fork and answers it without an external layer, which makes

## A crop's emissions are not bounded by the area it holds

**Issue**: the statistical leg gives each crop a cell's conversion emissions in proportion to the crop's share of the cell's expansion. The share is relative and is applied to an absolute amount of emissions, so a small absolute expansion can take a large share: a crop that expanded by 1 ha, in a cell where no other crop or pasture expanded, takes all of that cell's emissions however small its area or production there, and nothing in the factor, `emissions_mt / production_kg`, ties the two back together. The same symptom has a second cause: where the cropland map misses a crop's land, the crop's production stays in the denominator while the conversion behind it does not. That is the question of how much of a crop's land the cropland map finds, in "Woody perennial crops resolve to no destination".
**Issue**: the statistical leg gives each crop a cell's conversion emissions in proportion to the crop's share of the cell's expansion. The share is relative and is applied to an absolute amount of emissions, so a small absolute expansion can take a large share: a crop that expanded by 1 ha, in a cell where no other crop expanded, takes all of what that cell converted to cropland however small its area or production there, and nothing in the factor, `emissions_mt / production_kg`, ties the two back together. The same symptom has a second cause: where the cropland map misses a crop's land, the crop's production stays in the denominator while the conversion behind it does not. That is the question of how much of a crop's land the cropland map finds, in "Woody perennial crops resolve to no destination".

**Measured** on an earlier table, counting crops only (`PASTURE` and `DROPPED` left out, since including them shrinks every share about 4.6×): rows with a factor above 10 kg CO₂e/kg, which marks where to look rather than an error, carry 3.2% of the crops' emissions nationally and 9.3% provincially. 90% of those emissions are in rows over 10,000 ha, so this is not an effect of rows with tiny areas, and the `OTHER_*` catch-all crops carry 30% of it. The table had no livestock commodities and did not divide the peat drainage pulse by destination, so these figures need measuring again on the next release.

Expand Down
Loading