Skip to content

Bar doubled vowels in every Phi form - #719

Open
dcellison wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
forbid_doubled_vowels
Open

dcellison wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
forbid_doubled_vowels

Conversation

@dcellison

@dcellison dcellison commented Nov 19, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

Implements the ruling of 19 November 2026: no Phi form doubles a vowel, and names are not an exception.

The phonology reference already defined a vowel pair as two distinct vowels, and no lexicon word has ever broken that. The validator did not enforce it. python3 scripts/validate_examples.py name kaali reported a valid productive name, and the neighbors check would have let a lexical candidate with a doubled vowel through as well.

What changed

The word check in validate_examples.py and the name check in name_forms.py each reject a vowel that follows itself. The same two functions serve the lexicon, the neighbors and name commands, name atoms in documents, and the Tengwar renderer, so one rule covers all of them.

$ python3 scripts/validate_examples.py name kaali
'kaali' is not a valid productive name-form: contains a doubled vowel
$ python3 scripts/validate_examples.py neighbors keeno
'keeno' is not phonotactically legal: doubled vowel 'ee' (a vowel pair is two distinct vowels)

test_name_forms.py gains a regression test for both checks. It also confirms that an ordinary pair such as the one in kaeli still passes.

The ruling is recorded in canon.md beside the three-syllable ceiling and as D120 in the development log. The phonology reference gets a section 3.3. The protocol's phonology checklist, hiatus step, and name-form checklist name the rule. The manual's chapter on hiatus teaches it in two sentences, and the glossary entry for phonotactics lists it.

Wording to check

The canon bullet, the phonology reference, and the manual all give one reason for the rule: Phi has no long vowels, and two syllables of the same vowel with no onset between them would sound like one. That reason follows from the pronunciation ruling, which says no pair may become a single long vowel, but the wording here is new and the maintainer may prefer his own.

Effect on existing material

None. No lexicon word and no name anywhere in the texts, manual, primer, or pamphlets contains a doubled vowel, so nothing had to be renamed.

project/development_protocol.md is also touched by #718, on a different line. The two changes do not overlap.

Voice audit

The pass over the manual paragraph found one thing, after the first push: the sentence staged its example behind a colon ("No Phi word or name doubles a vowel: kaa would ask for..."). It is now two plain sentences, in a follow-up commit. The glossary clause and the reference text needed nothing.

Checks

Run locally on this branch, each as its own command:

  • python3 scripts/validate_examples.py: 1,305 entries, 0 errors, 0 warnings
  • python3 scripts/validate_sentences.py: 3,313 examples, 0 errors
  • python3 scripts/test_sentence_validator.py and python3 scripts/test_name_forms.py: OK
  • test_vocabulary_schema.py, content_vocabulary_decisions.py --check, test_content_vocabulary_decisions.py, test_translation_layers.py, translation_process_status.py --check, test_translation_process_status.py, source_reconstruction.py, test_source_reconstruction.py: all exit 0
  • python3 scripts/validate_sentences.py --docs: the same two diagnostics in documents/evaluation/narrative_test_corpus.md that the handoff already records, and nothing new
  • Generated references, the site build, and the phonetic-neighbor baseline were regenerated with no change to committed files.

Per-file ledger

File Change
scripts/validate_examples.py doubled-vowel check in the word-form function; header comment lists it
scripts/name_forms.py doubled-vowel check in the name-form function
scripts/test_name_forms.py one regression test covering both checks
canon.md new settled bullet
project/development_log.md D120
documents/reference/phonology_rules.md new section 3.3
project/development_protocol.md three checklist lines
manual/part3_phonology/ch08_music_of_phi/01_the_golden_rule.md one paragraph added
manual/appendices/appendix_a_glossary.md phonotactics entry lists the rule

A vowel pair is two different vowels. The phonology reference said so and the lexicon kept to it, but neither the word check nor the name check enforced the rule, so kaali passed as a productive name. Both checks now reject a vowel that follows itself.

Canon records the ruling, with decision D120 in the development log. The phonology reference, the protocol checklists, the manual's chapter on hiatus, and the glossary state the rule.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants