An interactive guessing game about immigration in the United States. Students make seven “out of 100” guesses about today and the past, see each real figure drawn as a grid of 100 people, and compare their guesses with what Americans guessed in a national survey. By Gwen Sharp.
Live site: https://gsharpokie.github.io/immigrantshare/
- Seven guesses: the share of U.S. residents who are immigrants; the shares of immigrants who were born in Mexico, who lack legal authorization, and who are Muslim; the share of workers who are immigrants; the immigrant share in 1970; and the share of today’s immigrants born in Europe (75 in 100 in 1960).
- Then and now: a line chart of the immigrant share of the population from 1850 to 2024, and bars comparing where immigrants were born in 1960 and 2024.
- After each guess: the student’s guess, the actual figure, and (where a survey asked) Americans’ average guess appear side by side as grids of 100 dots.
- The fuller picture: nearly everyone overestimates; people overestimate small groups in general; beliefs about who immigrants are matter more than how many there are; and the share is near a historic high but fell in 2025.
- Discussion questions.
To show all the answers without playing, add #answers to the link: https://gsharpokie.github.io/immigrantshare/#answers (this also shows the then-and-now charts)
- Actual figures: Pew Research Center, “What the Data Says about Immigrants in the U.S.” (August 21, 2025): 15.4% of U.S. residents and 19% of the labor force in June 2025; 22% of immigrants born in Mexico and 27% unauthorized in 2023. https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/08/21/key-findings-about-us-immigrants/
- What Americans guessed: Alesina, Alberto, Armando Miano and Stefanie Stantcheva. 2023. “Immigration and Redistribution.” Review of Economic Studies 90(1): 1–39. U.S. survey of 4,500 U.S.-born adults, January–February 2018: average guess 36% immigrants (actual 10% legal, 13.5% including unauthorized); average guess 23% of immigrants Muslim (actual about 10%).
- Why people overestimate small groups: Landy, David, Brian Guay and Tyler Marghetis. 2018. “Bias and Ignorance in Demographic Perception.” Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 25: 1606–1618.
- Immigrant share of the population, 1850–2010: 9.7, 13.2, 14.4, 13.3, 14.8, 13.6, 14.7, 13.2, 11.6, 8.8, 6.9, 5.4, 4.7, 6.2, 7.9, 11.1, 12.9 (each census 1850–2000; 2010 American Community Survey). U.S. Census Bureau, “America’s Foreign Born in the Last 50 Years” (2013), https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/visualizations/2013/comm/foreign-born.pdf, and Gibson and Jung (2006), Census Working Paper 81.
- 2024 share (14.8%), 2024 regions of birth (Latin America 51.4%, Asia 30.8%, Europe 9.7%, Africa 5.9%), and 1850 Europe share (92.2%): Gryn and Smith, “Foreign-Born Population in the United States Changed Significantly in Both Numbers and Countries of Origin,” U.S. Census Bureau, July 21, 2026. The 2024 “Other” value (2.2%) is the remainder.
- 1960 regions of birth (Europe 75%, Northern America 10%, Latin America 9%, Asia 5%, other 1%) and top countries (Italy, Germany, Canada, United Kingdom, Poland): the 2013 Census infographic above.
- Italy 13% of immigrants in 1960; Mexico 22% in 2024: Migration Policy Institute, “Frequently Requested Statistics on Immigrants and Immigration in the United States” (2026).
- From general knowledge, not checked against a source: the description of the 1920s national-origin quotas and their end in 1965.
Pew updates its immigrant fact sheet about once a year. Open index.html on GitHub, select the pencil icon, and in const Q = [ near the top of the <script> section change each question’s actual: number, its when: label, and its note: sentence. “The fuller picture” and “About the data” are plain text and need editing by hand.
Go to Settings → Pages. Under Build and deployment, set Source to Deploy from a branch, choose the main branch and the / (root) folder, and select Save. Keep Issues turned on so the “Suggest a correction” link works.
This site aims to meet WCAG 2.1 Level AA, so it works for people who use screen readers, keyboards, or screen magnification.
- All buttons, sliders, and links can be reached and used with a keyboard, and show a visible outline when selected.
- Charts have text descriptions, and many also have a data table or a slider that reads out each value.
- Text meets WCAG AA color contrast standards.
- Pages fit narrow phone screens without sideways scrolling.
I checked it in November 2026 with automated accessibility testing (axe-core) plus keyboard and small-screen checks. It hasn’t yet been tested by people who use screen readers every day, so there may be problems I haven’t caught. If something doesn’t work for you, please let me know.
Created by Gwen Sharp (@gsharpokie).
© 2026 Gwen Sharp. Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0: you may share and adapt it for noncommercial purposes with credit. See LICENSE. The figures belong to their sources; this license covers the page’s design, text, and code.