You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
[Bug]: t3_preview_list shows human-opened tabs without an explicit controllability signal, so agents burn turns attempting them #18294
I searched existing issues and did not find a duplicate.
I included enough detail to reproduce or investigate the problem.
Area
apps/server
Steps to reproduce
In a thread using the T3 preview browser, have the human open a tab (e.g. to log in to a site), so the thread holds both human-opened and agent-created tabs.
As the agent, call t3_preview_list.
Observe human tabs listed alongside agent tabs with the same shape. The only ownership signal is implicit: agent tabs carry automationOwner (no profileId); human tabs carry profileId (no automationOwner). There is no explicit per-tab owner/controllable flag.
Call preview_snapshot / preview_open with a human tabId.
Expected behavior
t3_preview_list marks each session with an explicit controllability signal for the caller (e.g. ownedByCaller / control.owner, mirroring what preview_* results already return), or it only lists / clearly partitions the tabs the caller can drive — so agents pick a usable tab on the first try instead of probing human tabs.
Actual behavior
The list invites the attempt. In a real session the agent attempted the human tab twice (preview_snapshot, then preview_open with reuse) before falling back to its own tabs:
preview_snapshot({"tabId":"<human-tab>"})
→ "This browser tab belongs to another agent session or a human. Open your own tab."
The refusal error is correct; the list is what misleads. It also disagrees with preview_* results, whose tabs arrays only include agent-owned tabs — so two list sources in the same thread show different tab sets.
Impact
Minor bug or occasional failure
It recurs whenever human and agent tabs coexist in one thread (attended-login workflows), and each occurrence costs the agent one or more wasted probing turns plus confusion about where the login actually lives.
preview_open({"tabId":"tab_7_…","reuseExistingTab":true,"open":true})
→ "This browser tab belongs to another agent session or a human. Open your own tab."
Workaround
Agent-side: treat tabs without automationOwner as not controllable; only drive tabs from preview_*tabs arrays. Human-side: log in inside an agent-created tab instead of opening your own tab.
Closing this. Current main already gives agents the signal you're asking for. It just lives in the preview_* results, not in t3_preview_list.
The tabs array in preview_* results lists every tab in the thread, including tabs a human opened. Each entry has owner and ownedByCaller (ServerBrowser.ts, the tabs: filter checks only threadId). So the two sources show the same set of tabs, not different ones.
Workaround: pick the tab to drive using ownedByCaller from a preview_* result. A tab with no automationOwner in t3_preview_list isn't yours. If you'd like ownedByCaller added to t3_preview_list itself, please open that in Ideas. If you can reproduce a snapshot refusal on a human tab on the latest nightly, comment and we'll reopen.
Activity
juliusmarminge commentedon Oct 11, 2026
Note
Grok responding on behalf of Julius.
Closing this. Current main already gives agents the signal you're asking for. It just lives in the
preview_*results, not int3_preview_list.tabsarray inpreview_*results lists every tab in the thread, including tabs a human opened. Each entry hasownerandownedByCaller(ServerBrowser.ts, thetabs:filter checks onlythreadId). So the two sources show the same set of tabs, not different ones.preview_snapshot,status, andwaitForare read operations and are allowed on any tab in the thread. Only acting on a tab requires owning it, which stays intentional per [Bug]: Agents ignore the default browser profile, cannot accept human-opened tabs, and cannot select another profile #16701.Workaround: pick the tab to drive using
ownedByCallerfrom apreview_*result. A tab with noautomationOwnerint3_preview_listisn't yours. If you'd likeownedByCalleradded tot3_preview_listitself, please open that in Ideas. If you can reproduce a snapshot refusal on a human tab on the latest nightly, comment and we'll reopen.