Skip to content

OAuth approval fails with “Sign-in cannot continue” for Muse MCP connector despite reachable T3 Connect environment #39242

Open

Description

@junwong0310-hash

Summary

I am experiencing an OAuth approval failure when connecting Muse Desktop 10.1 to an isolated T3 Code Beta 0.1.10 environment through the official T3 Connect managed HTTPS relay.

Muse successfully completes dynamic client registration and reaches the T3-hosted OAuth authorization flow.

However, the hosted approval page displays:

“Sign-in cannot continue”

The failure occurs before the approval details are displayed and before I can review or approve the requested read-only access.

During the failure window, the isolated T3 environment remains registered and responds to independent anonymous MCP requests.

The underlying cause remains unknown.

Environment

  • Operating system: macOS (Apple Silicon)
  • Muse Desktop: 10.1
  • T3 Code: Beta 0.1.10
  • Relay client: Official cloudflared 2026.10.4
  • Relay transport: HTTP/2
  • Remote access: Official T3 Connect managed HTTPS endpoint
  • Test environment: Isolated T3 instance containing one synthetic project
  • Test data: Zero threads and zero AI executions

No production projects or real user data were included in the isolated environment.

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Complete the official T3 CLI device authorization flow for the isolated environment.
  2. Verify that the CLI successfully receives and stores its temporary authentication credentials.
  3. Send a separate authenticated HTTP request to the official T3 Connect environment registry using the credential obtained through CLI device sign-in, and verify that it returns HTTP 200.
  4. Link the isolated T3 environment through the official T3 Connect workflow.
  5. Verify that the registered environment matches the HTTPS endpoint configured in the dedicated Muse connector.
  6. Confirm that anonymous MCP initialization returns HTTP 401 and both OAuth discovery endpoints return HTTP 200.
  7. Select Connect in the existing Muse MCP connector.
  8. Allow Muse to initiate OAuth client registration and authorization.
  9. Open the T3-hosted authorization page while keeping the isolated server and relay operational.
  10. Observe the authorization page before the read-only approval details appear.

Expected Behavior

The hosted authorization page should retrieve the approval details for the registered isolated environment.

The user should be able to review the requesting application, inspect the requested OAuth permissions, and approve or deny access, including selecting read-only access without granting execution permissions.

If approved, the OAuth flow should continue to the authorization-code exchange and authenticated MCP connection.

Actual Behavior

The hosted approval page displays:

“Sign-in cannot continue”

The approval details do not appear, and the user cannot complete the approval.

No successful approval decision, Muse OAuth token exchange, authenticated MCP initialization, or project-reading operation was observed.

The isolated environment remained registered and reachable through an independent anonymous MCP probe during the reported failure window.

Verified OAuth and Network Evidence

Operation Observed Result
CLI device sign-in Completed successfully; temporary credential obtained
Separate authenticated HTTP request to the official T3 Connect environment registry HTTP 200 using the credential obtained through CLI device sign-in
Anonymous MCP initialization HTTP 401
OAuth protected-resource discovery HTTP 200
OAuth authorization-server discovery HTTP 200
Dynamic client registration HTTP 201
OAuth authorization request HTTP 302
Requested OAuth scope orchestration:read
Approval details request No matching request observed in the retained isolated-server trace
Approval decision No matching request observed
Muse OAuth token exchange Not observed
Authenticated Muse MCP initialization Not observed
Project and thread tool responses Not observed

The successful anonymous MCP probe confirms that the isolated endpoint was reachable from the probing client.

It does not establish that the hosted approval page successfully resolved the environment, obtained the necessary authorization credentials, or reached the protected approval endpoint.

The retained trace also includes successful T3 Connect credential requests and a successful request to a separate /oauth/token endpoint.

These operations are distinct from the Muse MCP OAuth token exchange and should not be interpreted as proof that Muse authorization succeeded.

Relevant Timeline

All timestamps are from November 19, 2026, in UTC.

Time (UTC) Observation
16:36:56 Official CLI device authorization completed successfully.
Approximately 16:37 A separate authenticated HTTP request to the official T3 Connect environment registry returned HTTP 200 using the credential obtained through CLI device sign-in.
16:44:21–16:44:24 Official HTTP/2 relay connections registered.
16:44:34 Anonymous MCP initialization returned HTTP 401.
16:45:38–16:45:40 OAuth discovery endpoints returned HTTP 200.
16:46:31 Muse dynamic client registration returned HTTP 201.
16:46:45 OAuth authorization returned HTTP 302.
16:47:18–16:47:30 T3 Connect credential requests returned HTTP 200.
Approximately 16:48–16:49 Hosted approval page displayed “Sign-in cannot continue.”
16:48:12 Independent anonymous MCP probe returned HTTP 401.
After 16:49 Cleanup began following the reported error.

The timestamps are based on retained sanitized logs and the observed browser error window.

Troubleshooting Already Performed

1. Verified CLI Authentication

The official device authorization completed successfully, and the CLI obtained and stored usable credentials.

An authenticated request to the official T3 Connect environment registry returned HTTP 200 using the credential obtained through CLI device sign-in.

The registry query was a separate HTTP operation, not a registry query performed directly by the CLI.

2. Verified Environment Registration

The isolated environment appeared in the official account registry.

The registered HTTPS endpoint matched the endpoint configured in the Muse connector.

3. Verified Relay Availability

The official cloudflared relay established HTTP/2 connections.

An independent MCP request reached the isolated server during the reported authorization failure.

4. Verified OAuth Registration and Redirect

Muse successfully registered its OAuth client.

The authorization request passed server-side validation and returned HTTP 302.

The requested scope was limited to orchestration:read.

This was the requested scope, not a verified granted scope.

5. Ruled Out Premature Relay Shutdown for This Attempt

An earlier test included a possible race between OAuth approval and relay cleanup.

In the controlled reproduction, the relay remained operational throughout the observed failure.

Cleanup began only after the authorization error was reported.

Therefore, premature relay shutdown does not explain this particular reproduction.

6. Reviewed Related Upstream Changes

I reviewed PR #33645, which addresses an approval-decision failure involving session validation after approval details have already loaded.

That fix is included in T3 Code 0.1.10.

The current failure occurs before approval details are successfully retrieved, so I cannot establish that it is the same issue.

Questions for Maintainers

I would appreciate guidance on the following:

  1. Which component or service path can produce “Sign-in cannot continue” before the hosted approval details are displayed?
  2. Is there a supported way to distinguish between environment lookup failure, browser account-session failure, T3 Connect credential issuance failure, protected approval-endpoint failure, and an internal hosted approval-service error?
  3. Is this behavior a known issue affecting T3 Code Beta 0.1.10?
  4. Is there a verified fix or recommended supported release specifically addressing this failure stage?
  5. Can the hosted approval flow provide a non-sensitive diagnostic identifier or error category that users can safely include in bug reports?
  6. Is there an officially supported read-only workaround that avoids the failing hosted approval step?
  7. Would additional sanitized timestamps or route-level diagnostic information help with triage?

Security and Privacy

The test used an isolated environment containing only synthetic data.

Temporary authorization sessions and the remote environment registration were removed after testing.

No AI execution or paid API calls occurred.

This report intentionally excludes access tokens, refresh tokens, authorization codes, device codes, session cookies, sensitive OAuth URLs, private account identifiers, environment identifiers, local filesystem paths, and unredacted authentication screenshots.

I can provide additional sanitized diagnostic information if the maintainers identify a safe and supported collection procedure.

Thank you for your assistance.

Activity

  1. juliusmarminge commented on Nov 19, 2026

    @juliusmarminge
    Member

    @junwong0310-hash What exact text appears directly under 'This sign-in cannot continue' on the approval page? If it says 'Could not reach that environment through T3 Connect with this account.', please confirm whether the browser was signed in to app.t3.codes with the same T3 Connect account you used for the CLI device sign-in that linked the environment. If it was a different account, 'Use another account' on that page should let you finish.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    needs more infoInitial triage showed no bug. Awaiting more info

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions