Repository navigation
feat(mcp): URL allowlisting and SSRF defense on search and paid call (closes #404, closes #407) - #449
Conversation
Miracle656
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Changes requested: one issue per PR, and only issues assigned to you
This is a process requirement, applied to all 23 of your open PRs in this repo. It is not a judgement about the code, which I have not been able to review — and that is the first half of the problem.
The bundling
Across your open PRs, 150 distinct issues are claimed. This one claims several. #483 claims 22, #481 claims 20, #477 claims 20, #474 claims 20.
A PR that closes twenty issues cannot be reviewed. Each of those issues has its own acceptance criteria — typically five — so twenty issues is a hundred separate things to verify in one diff, and if any one of them is wrong the whole PR is blocked while it is fixed. Every batch I published says the issues are deliberately independent so they can be worked in parallel, by different people, without colliding. Bundling them removes exactly that property.
The assignments
135 of the 150 issues claimed are assigned to other contributors — 67 different people.
This PR is an example: it names issues currently assigned to other contributors who are working on them now. Several have open PRs of their own. If this merged as it stands, those people would have done the work and received nothing for it, and I would have no way to tell the two efforts apart.
I am not assuming anything about why. Assignments change, Drips and GitHub can disagree, and a wide-ranging branch picks up issue numbers easily. But the effect on the people holding those assignments is the same regardless of intent, which is why I have to act on it.
What I need
- One issue per PR. The issue number in the title, its acceptance criteria met, and nothing else in the diff.
- Only issues assigned to you, or unassigned ones you have claimed through Drips. If an issue is assigned to someone else, it is theirs.
- Re-open the work that meets both conditions as individual PRs. I will review them in the order they arrive and at the same pace as everyone else's.
Nothing is being closed. These stay open and are yours to re-cut, withdraw or split as you choose.
Two things worth knowing before you re-cut
Some of this has already landed. #488 (SSRF guard for bazaar_search) and #487 (the paid_call host allow-list) cover the same ground as your #449; #486 covers the MCP README. Check current main before rebuilding something that is already there.
main has moved a long way today — #306, #309, #252, #256, #355, #381, #390, #402, #476, #488 and more. Cut from current main, not from where these branches started.
If you believe an issue named here is genuinely yours, say which and I will check the assignment myself — I would rather be corrected than have someone lose work.
Summary
Addresses and resolves issues #404 and #407 by introducing strict host allowlisting, URL scheme validation, and post-DNS SSRF defense with redirect inspection for the Bazaar MCP server.
Key Changes
Host Allowlist for paid_call (
paid_callwill pay whatever URL the agent names #404):otstellar.org, stellar.org.attacker.com).
SSRF Defense & URL Validation for �azaar_search (
bazaar_searchwill fetch any URL it is given #407):New MCP Error Codes:
Changeset & Tests:
Closes #404
Closes #407